The 2025 Irish Presidential Election has been anything but ordinary. This election isn’t just a contest for Áras an Uachtaráin, it’s a referendum on Ireland’s political identity, values, and future direction.
On 24 October, voters will choose between two starkly different contenders:
Catherine Connolly: the insurgent independent with grassroots firepower and left-wing momentum.
Heather Humphreys: the seasoned Government Minister turned centrist candidate, promising unity and stability.
This is a race defined not by policy platforms – but by personality, positioning, and political symbolism.
Connolly: The Firebrand
Catherine Connolly’s entry into the race in July was a jolt to the political establishment. Backed by all left-wing parties in the Dáil, her campaign mobilised over 5,000 volunteers and raised €50,000 through small donations in the 5 weeks following her campaign launch – a testament to her grassroots appeal.
Connolly presents herself as the people’s voice: fluent in Irish, unapologetically progressive, and unafraid to challenge the status quo. Her campaign has leaned heavily into themes of neutrality, foreign policy independence, social justice, and solidarity – particularly her vocal support for Palestinian rights and Irish unity.
But authenticity is a double-edged sword. Connolly’s past decisions, including hiring a staffer with a firearms conviction and her 2018 visit to Syria under the Assad regime, have drawn media scrutiny. Critics point to a perceived “softness” on Russia and question her judgment on international affairs.
These controversies risk alienating moderate voters, especially those who value diplomatic caution and centrist pragmatism. Connolly’s challenge is to convert passion into broad appeal, without diluting her message.
Humphreys: The Bridge-Builder
Heather Humphreys, Fine Gael’s candidate since September, emerged from an internal contest with 38 parliamentary backers. Her campaign has been carefully choreographed to present her as a unifying figure, not a partisan one.
Humphreys has received endorsements from across the political spectrum, including three former Tánaistí (Deputy PMs) from different parties. Notably, despite Labour’s official backing of Connolly, former Labour Leaders Alan Kelly & Brendan Howlin, as well as former TD Mary Upton, have publicly supported Humphreys, signalling a fracture in traditional party loyalties.
Her campaign style has been old school: community-focused, personable, and grounded. From serving ice cream, to making coffees in local cafés, and quite literally shaking hands and kissing babies, Humphreys is leaning into the retail politics playbook.
Yet her biggest hurdle is her long association with government. As a TD since 2011 and Minister from 2014 to 2024, she is inextricably linked to Fine Gael’s record – including austerity measures and controversial decisions post-financial crisis. While her team argues that Fine Gael showed strong leadership in challenging times, Humphreys herself has pointed to her personal achievements in government, all the while demonstrating caution about trumpeting her party’s legacy too loudly, preferring to focus on the non-partisan nature of the presidency.
In an era of anti-establishment sentiment, Humphreys must convince voters that her experience is an asset, and not a liability.
Northern Ireland: A Presidential Lens
The implications of this election extend beyond the Republic. Northern Ireland is watching closely.
Connolly has been forthright in her support for Irish unity. She has called for the Irish Government to actively pursue reunification. Her alignment with Sinn Féin strengthens her credentials among unity advocates – but may undermine her standing with unionists in Northern Ireland.
If elected, her challenge lies in navigating the complex identity politics of Northern Ireland. Can she build trust across traditional divides while remaining true to her principles?
Humphreys, meanwhile, has taken a more measured approach. She argues that the priority should be to “build trust” between North and South, rather than rushing toward referenda. As the first Ulster Protestant to knock on the door of the Áras, her candidacy carries symbolic weight – with the potential to mark a quantum leap for reconciliation efforts.
For voters who see Irish unity as a long-term goal requiring empathy and bridge-building, Humphreys may offer a more palatable path.
The Jim Gavin Factor
The race took a dramatic turn with the unexpected exit of the Fianna Fáil candidate, Jim Gavin. His departure sent shockwaves through Fianna Fáil and left a vacuum in the centrist voting bloc.
Conventional wisdom suggests that Gavin’s supporters may drift toward Humphreys – but it’s not guaranteed. Fianna Fáil voters may feel uneasy turning out to place a #1 beside a Fine Gael candidate, given the controversy surrounding Gavin’s candidacy and the historical rivalry between the two parties.
Presidential elections often suffer from low turnout and voter apathy, and the Gavin fallout could exacerbate that. Transfer patterns from the last general election indicated that around 45% of Fianna Fáil voters continued down the ballot for Fine Gael, while 60% of Fine Gael voters returned the favour. But whether those dynamics hold in a presidential contest remains uncertain.
A Test of Ireland’s Political Mood
The 2025 Presidential election is more than just a choice between two candidates, it serves as both a barometer for the mood across the country, and a window into the core values of the nation.
Do voters want authenticity, disruption, and moral clarity? (Connolly)
Or do they crave experience, unity, and reassurance? (Humphreys)
The final weeks won’t be decided by new policies or manifestos. They’ll be shaped by narrative control, emotional resonance, and the ability to persuade the undecided.
As it stands, Catherine Connolly is the choice of 38% of voters, Heather Humphreys sits at 20%, with Jim Gavin registering 5%. 18% of voters are still undecided, 12% say they won’t vote, and 6% intend to spoil their ballot. (Source: The Irish Times Ipsos B&A Opinion Poll, 16th October 2025)
Final Thought
As Ireland stands at a political crossroads, the 2025 Presidential election offers a rare moment of reflection.
It’s a chance to ask:
What kind of leadership do voters value?
How do voters balance principle with pragmatism?
And who do voters trust to represent Ireland – not just at home, but on the world stage?
Is Ireland ready for a disruptor – or does it need a steady hand?
If you’ve got any questions, or want to explore how this election impacts your organisation, please contact us here.
