A holding budget, with the big decisions still to come. 

By Emma Barnes – Director

John Healey opened last week’s budget by setting out the context, and it was a difficult one. He talked about a storm coming rather than the usual fiscal headwinds: the Iran conflict, global oil prices and high inflation expected next year. All of that limits the money he has to spend on the things the Government wants to do.

That’s important because Andy Burnham came in with some really big ambitions, and the budget delivered little of them. Instead we got small, incremental changes, with Healey using much of his headroom to absorb them: £100 off bills for households in the lowest council tax bands, and an end to gas standing charges from 2027. “Breathing space”, as he called it. There’s lots he’d like to do, but not much room to do it right now.

What was missing?

What struck me most was how many of the big decisions are being made somewhere else. Alan Milburn’s review of welfare and young people hasn’t reported yet. The Prime Minister’s ten-year plan is due in December. And the real choices about who gets what will come in next year’s spending review. A lot of what the Government wants to do depends on those three, so it makes sense that the budget held back. I’d call it a holding budget. There’s more to come; the Government just needs time to work it out.

The ten-year plan is the big one. It’s due in mid-December and is being drafted now, organised around three stages of life: growing up, getting on and growing old. Treasury officials are reportedly waiting for it to see which priorities to protect in the spending review and where savings can be found.

And savings will be needed. The IFS thinks the Treasury has to find around £28bn by 2030: £17bn to keep up with inflation and £11bn to reach 3% of GDP on defence. Ministers have already said not every department will get a real-terms increase. So if your sector is a priority in the plan, you’ll be in a much better position next autumn. If it isn’t, that’s a risk.

What “public control” might mean:

The other thing to watch is what Burnham means by “public control” of utilities. His team are clear it doesn’t just mean nationalisation. They point to the Bee Network in Manchester, where the buses are publicly controlled but still privately run. We’ve already had some signals: the ban on public ownership of water companies is going, there’s a new publicly owned Great British Grid, and regulators and arm’s-length bodies look likely to be reformed.

There was a really interesting example of how this might work in the budget itself: the new data centre covenant. Data centres waiting in the grid connection queue will be able to generate their own electricity, and they’ll get preferential access to the grid. In return, developers will be expected to invest in local communities, create jobs and protect local water supplies. We’ll need to see the detail, but I think that kind of deal, where the Government offers help in exchange for clear local benefits, is something we’ll see more of across energy, infrastructure and property.

What organisations should be doing:

A few things I’d be thinking about now:

  • What policies are holding you back? The focus on small incremental changes isn’t going anywhere, despite the criticism. If you have small wins, push them.  
  • Show what you deliver locally, and when. The plan is expected to set out short, medium and long-term action in each policy area. Ministers want things they can point to, so make that easy for them.
  • Work out where you stand ahead of the spending review. It’s likely to contain significant departmental cuts. What do you need to make the case for keeping?
  • Plan for an election in 2027. With so much still to come, I think this points to an election next year rather than one this side of Christmas, though we’ll have to wait and see. Either way, the Government has more to do to convince voters, and I’d expect plenty of new policy over the next three to six months. 

So the budget wasn’t the big moment some people were expecting. But I’d keep a close eye on December. The next few months could bring significant change. If you’d like to discuss what the evolving policy landscape means for your organisation, get in touch with our team here.

Keep reading…