When populists talk to populists: political disagreement is becoming box office. 

By Gareth Morgan – Executive Director

Nearly two million YouTube subscribers. More than half a billion views. And a growing presence in one of the most influential political and cultural networks in the world.

Not bad for a British podcast started by two (very average) stand-up comedians in 2018.

Triggernometry, hosted by Kisin and Francis Foster, has evolved from a relatively niche show into an increasingly influential platform for political debate.

Over the past two years, its hosts have become more deeply embedded in the transatlantic podcasting ecosystem. They’ve appeared repeatedly on Joe Rogan’s hugely influential show and have developed connections with a wider network of American comedians (Theo Von etc..), commentators and cultural figures.

Their own guest list has included figures from that world, alongside British politicians and commentators. Kisin (the more serious of the two hosts) has also attracted repeated engagement from Elon Musk on X.

The show presents itself as a forum for open conversation and free speech. But much of its appeal has been built around challenging progressive orthodoxies, identity politics, diversity initiatives and what its hosts see as the excesses of woke culture.

It’s part of a wider ecosystem of podcasts, YouTube channels and social media personalities that has developed substantial political influence outside traditional media institutions.

But something particularly interesting is happening within it.

Last year, Triggernometry controversially interviewed Tommy Robinson (themselves following the example of Jordan Petersen). That episode has attracted around 2.4 million views.

Most recently, Owen Jones has also appeared for a nearly two-hour conversation. Jones is one of Britain’s most prominent voices on the populist left. Kisin occupies a very different political space.

So why are left and right populists increasingly talking to each other?

There’s an encouraging/naive interpretation. At a time of intense political polarisation, people with fundamentally opposing views are prepared to sit down and argue their positions.

Hmmmm.

I suspect something else is happening.

The political left and right have discovered that their disagreements are box office.

Neither Jones nor Kisin was particularly likely to change the other’s mind. But the clash itself is compelling content. It generates views, clips, reactions, arguments and further engagement.

That episode alone has attracted more than 750,000 views and over 14,000 comments on YouTube, even before taking into account the reach of clips and extracts subsequently shared across other platforms.

And the platforms on which these conversations take place have incentives that can reward precisely this sort of confrontation.

It’s a dynamic familiar to anyone who spends time on X, where contentious political exchanges can spread rapidly through networks of supporters, opponents and commentators.

The paradox is that polarisation and platform dynamics are bringing opposing political voices into closer contact, without necessarily bringing their political positions any closer together.

And the consequences extend well beyond the audiences watching these conversations.

We can look at another recent example.

In October, Tucker Carlson (hugely influential American right-wing broadcaster and political provocateur) interviewed Jacob Rees-Mogg. Their conversation went viral after the former Conservative minister challenged Carlson’s arguments about Britain’s involvement in the Second World War.

An exchange on an American podcast became a major British news story, provoking political reaction and widespread coverage.

These platforms aren’t simply responding to the mainstream political agenda. Increasingly, they’re helping to set it.

This is an area we’ve been examining closely at Cavendish.

Our research mapping Britain’s 50 most influential populist voices across the left and right identified Jones as the most influential figure on the left, with Kisin among the leading voices on the populist right.

We undertook that work because we believed the traditional map of political influence was becoming increasingly inadequate.

For organisations trying to understand the political and reputational environment in which they operate, it’s no longer enough to follow ministers, regulators, newspaper editors and conventional broadcasters.

They need to understand the new ecosystems of influence. Who commands attention? Which audiences overlap? How do arguments move between Britain and America? And how does a conversation on YouTube become a political controversy, a mainstream news story or a challenge to an organisation’s reputation?

Crucially, they also need to understand the incentives shaping those conversations.

Because polarisation isn’t simply a feature of our politics.

It’s increasingly part of the business model of political influence.

Get in touch with our team here to understand the new networks of political influence and what they mean for you.

Still from Owen Jones vs. TRIGGERnometry. Credit: Triggernometry / YouTube. Used for commentary and review. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VqIByeaby7I

Keep reading…